College applicants face standard test crisis

There is growing controversy in this country about the role that standardized tests should play in college admissions. More than 1,800 schools in the U.S. require students to submit SAT or ACT results, according to the National Center for Fair and Open Testing.

Many of these policies were adopted during the Pandemic. Then, last week, the State University system in California, the nation’s largest four – year school system, announced that it was making the change permanent and that tests would not be considered. This week, on the East Coast, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology announced that it was reinstating the need to conduct a test.

Both moves are in the name of equality and access. What should a confused high school junior do?

High schools have been filling bubbles for decades.

“We have been around since 1959,” said Janet Godwin, CEO of ACT, which conducts ACT exams. She said the exam was created to prove that they are ready for college to help college students, including veterans returning from the war.

“This is objective and standardized information that can be used by students and teachers – very different from the high school grade point average, for example, it is very subjective and very different from one district to another,” she said.

You know that the test is standard across the country, so a good score will help a student who is not going to a strong high school.

But opponents of the experiment, along with Akhil Bello, a non-profit National Center for Fair and Open Testing, say the idea of ​​an “experimental diamond” is wrong.

Bello said students from wealthy backgrounds are more likely to perform well on these exams. “The test benefits a particular group of students and adversely affects students who claim the test helped.”

Now, as more schools change the way they consider test scores, college counselors are changing the way they talk about them.

“Testing has always been part of the conversation, hasn’t it? ‘Which are you taking? When are you going to pick it up? ” Said Patrick Lorenzo, college counselor at St. Ignatius College Preparatory, a private high school in San Francisco. “Now, the question is, ‘Do you want to take this?’ You do not have to.

It gives students more power, Lorenzo said, allowing other qualities to shine through in their applications.

Leave a Comment